- Coaches Hot Seat
- Posts
- The Big Ten's Championship Chaos: Why 2025 Could Break College Football's Biggest Programs
The Big Ten's Championship Chaos: Why 2025 Could Break College Football's Biggest Programs
From Iowa's quarterback gamble to Ohio State's impossible repeat bid, four powerhouse programs face make-or-break seasons as the sport transforms into a $20 million professional enterprise


IN THIS ISSUE
Welcome! The House Settlement has been finalized, allowing schools to pay athletes directly. We have linked to coverage below. If this issue was forwarded to you, click below to subscribe.
DEEP DIVE
Big Ten Week 4: The Uncomfortable Truth About Expectations
Here's what nobody wants to admit about this week's Big Ten previews: three of these four programs are about to learn painful lessons about the gap between hope and reality.
Ohio State just won a national championship and lost 14 players to the NFL Draft—but everyone still expects them to repeat. That's not how college football works. Penn State has its best roster in decades and championship-or-bust expectations, which means anything short of perfection feels like failure. Minnesota sits at a crossroads where P.J. Fleck either proves he belongs with the Big Ten elite or watches that window slam shut forever.
And then there's Iowa, finally admitting their offensive philosophy was broken and bringing in a two-time FCS national champion quarterback to fix it.
The math is simple: expectations have never been higher, margin for error has never been smaller, and three of these programs are probably going to disappoint their fan bases.
The question isn't whether these teams are talented—they all are. The question is whether they can handle the pressure of their success.
Let's find out who cracks first.

You’re doing breakfast wrong
Let’s face it—most breakfast options just don’t cut it.
Toast? Too light. Cereal? Mostly sugar. Skipping it altogether? Not ideal.
If you want real fuel to power your day, it’s time to upgrade to Huel Black Edition. This ready-in-seconds shake is packed with 40g of plant-based protein, 27 essential vitamins & minerals, and 0 artificial sweeteners—just science-backed nutrition to support your muscles, digestion, and more.
Oh, and did we mention? It’s delicious.
Right now, first-time customers get 15% off, plus a free t-shirt and shaker with code HUELSPRING, for orders over $75.

BEST LINKS
College athletics enters a revolutionary new era as a federal judge approves the NCAA's landmark House settlement, allowing schools to directly pay athletes for the first time in history.
$2.8 billion in backpay will be distributed to thousands of former athletes from 2016-2024 who were denied name, image, and likeness compensation
Schools can now share up to $20.5 million annually with their athletes, starting July 1, with most programs planning to allocate 90% of the funds to football and men's basketball.
New enforcement system launches immediately, featuring a Deloitte-run clearinghouse that must approve all third-party NIL deals worth $600 or more to prevent booster abuse.
This groundbreaking settlement fundamentally transforms college sports from an amateur model to a professionalized system where student-athletes can finally receive direct compensation from their schools.
The rapid commercialization of college sports is leaving faculty athletics representatives (FARs) behind, as these academic watchdogs find themselves increasingly shut out of major policy decisions, despite their NCAA-mandated role.
Faculty reps are being systematically excluded from key governance discussions, including a new NCAA working group that had "no oversight" in omitting any academic voices from revenue-sharing decisions.
The role is becoming unsustainable as demands increase exponentially while compensation remains stagnant—some FARs dedicate 50% of their workload to athletics duties for minimal additional pay.
Academic integrity faces new threats as schools prepare to share tens of millions in revenue with athletes. Yet, the very people tasked with protecting educational standards are being pushed to the sidelines.
As college athletics transforms into a professional enterprise, the marginalization of faculty oversight signals a troubling abandonment of the academic mission that supposedly defines collegiate sports.

DEEP DIVE
Big Ten Week 4 Previews: Minnesota, Penn State, Ohio State, Iowa
Minnesota Golden Gophers
P.J. Fleck's 2025 season isn't just important—it's the difference between proving Minnesota belongs with the Big Ten elite or watching that window slam shut forever.
The defense, which allowed just 16.9 points per game, is back almost entirely intact, led by safety Koi Perich and a front seven that suffocated opposing offenses with a remarkable 91% fourth-down stop rate.
The transfer portal makeover was surgical, not desperate—A.J. Turner from Marshall, Javon Tracy from Miami-OH, and offensive linemen who outrecruited Ohio State addresses every 2024 weakness.
Drake Lindsey steps into the quarterback void with zero margin for error, replacing steady Max Brosmer. At the same time, the entire season hinges on whether a redshirt freshman can handle Big Ten pressure.
The schedule tells two stories: manageable home games against Rutgers, Purdue, and Wisconsin, but road trips to Ohio State and Oregon that could turn into bloodbaths if the offensive line doesn't gel immediately.
Win total sits at 6.5, but that feels conservative for a program that's exceeded expectations five of the last six seasons—the ceiling is a Big Ten title game if everything clicks, the floor is missing bowl games entirely.
Either Minnesota proves they belong in the conversation with Ohio State and Michigan, or 2025 becomes another "what if" season in a program that's had too many already.
Penn State Nittany Lions
After 13 wins and a playoff semifinal heartbreak, Penn State enters 2025 with championship-or-bust expectations and zero excuses left.
Drew Allar isn't just the quarterback—he's carrying Heisman Trophy hopes and an entire program's championship dreams, with +1400 odds and the weapons to finally break through after jumping from 59.9% to 66.5% completion rate.
Roster continuity is unprecedented in the transfer portal era, with 14 starters returning while strategic additions like Syracuse's Trebor Pena (84 catches, 941 yards) address the explosive receiver need.
Jim Knowles' $3.1 million hiring as defensive coordinator represents the boldest championship move, bringing Ohio State-level schemes to a defense that already features potential All-Americans in Zane Durant and A.J. Harris.
The schedule presents both opportunity and danger—Oregon at home in the White Out, road tests at Iowa and Ohio State where Franklin's 1-18 record against AP Top 5 teams must finally improve.
James Franklin's 12-year tenure faces its ultimate test with an 85% fan approval rating but growing whispers that anything short of a championship feels like failure—the foundation is built, the resources are there, the moment has arrived.
This isn't just another season with high expectations—it's the culmination of everything Franklin has built, and the answer will define both 2025 and his legacy in Happy Valley.
Ohio State Buckeyes
The most dangerous thing about winning a championship is everyone expecting you to do it again—and Ohio State is about to learn this lesson the hard way.
Nobody knows who the starting quarterback will be just months before facing Texas in the opener, with Julian Sayin looking shaky in spring practice and Lincoln Kienholz emerging as a potential competitor, while coaches admit they're "a long way away" from making a decision.
Losing 14 players to the NFL Draft isn't a reload—it's a complete teardown, including the entire starting defensive line that generated 53 sacks and Will Howard, who threw for 4,010 yards during the championship run.
Brian Hartline got the most pressure-packed promotion in college football, jumping from receivers coach to offensive coordinator for defending champions with no starting quarterback and the expectation to match last year's explosive offense.
Matt Patricia's hiring as defensive coordinator signals desperation more than confidence—when you call a former NFL head coach who went 13-29-1 in Detroit to save your defense, you're admitting the situation is dire.
The schedule from hell opens with Texas at noon, then includes road games at Washington, Illinois, Wisconsin, and Michigan—designed for a championship team, not a rebuilding squad relying on transfer portal band-aids.
Either Ohio State's coaching staff knows something we don't about this massive rebuild, or they're about to learn a costly lesson about overconfidence and the impossibility of repeating in the modern era.
Iowa Hawkeyes
Mark Gronowski changes everything for Iowa football—the two-time FCS national champion represents the most significant offensive upgrade the Hawkeyes have made in years.
The quarterback revolution begins with a proven winner who went 49-6 as a starter at South Dakota State, bringing 3,058 passing yards and 29 touchdowns from his 2023 Walter Payton Award season to a program that averaged just 131.6 passing yards per game.
Tim Lester's offensive overhaul is systematic, not cosmetic—adding Warren Ruggiero as senior analyst, recruiting Sam Phillips from Chattanooga for speed, and implementing a West Coast system designed for Gronowski's dual-threat capabilities.
The defense maintains excellence under Phil Parker despite losing Jay Higgins and key contributors, with Aaron Graves and Ethan Hurkett anchoring a defensive line that continues producing NFL talent through Iowa's development system.
The schedule presents both opportunity and nightmare scenarios—hosting three College Football Playoff teams (Indiana, Penn State, Oregon) at Kinnick while navigating road tests at Iowa State, Wisconsin, USC, and Nebraska that could derail momentum.
Win total sits at 7.5, reflecting cautious optimism about offensive upgrades and recognition that Iowa is 0-6 against Penn State, Michigan, and Ohio State since 2021, being outscored 215-34 in those contests.
For a program built on development, defense, and overachievement, 2025 represents the chance to prove that strategic upgrades can coexist with traditional Iowa values—the quarterback revolution starts now.

THAT’S A WRAP
Looking Ahead: The Big Ten Revolution Continues
College football has never moved this fast.
What we've witnessed across these four Big Ten programs tells the story of a sport in complete transformation. Iowa is betting everything on Mark Gronowski to finally solve their offensive puzzle. Ohio State is discovering that winning championships creates impossible expectations when you lose 14 players to the NFL. Penn State enters their ultimate championship-or-bust season with Drew Allar carrying Heisman hopes. Minnesota sits at a crossroads where P.J. Fleck must prove his program belongs among the Big Ten elite.
The New Reality of College Athletics
Meanwhile, the sport itself is being revolutionized in real-time:
The NCAA's House settlement allows schools to pay athletes up to $20.5 million annually
$2.8 billion in backpay will flow to former athletes denied compensation
Faculty oversight is being systematically eliminated as athletics becomes pure business
What's Coming Next Week
We'll complete our Big Ten deep dive with three more programs:
Oregon's championship machinery and playoff expectations
Indiana's continued rise under Curt Cignetti
Illinois's rebuild in the new conference landscape
Then we pivot to the SEC, where similar pressures and opportunities are reshaping the most competitive conference in college football.
The revolution isn't coming—it's already here.
Every program must evolve or risk being left behind, and next week we'll see how the rest of the Big Ten and the SEC's powerhouses are adapting to this brave new world of college athletics.
What did you think of today's newsletter?Have an idea or feedback? Hit reply to this email and send me a note. I read every response. |
Reply